Solsticewitch13's BOS: Facts, Fallacies and Bigots

Tuesday, August 25, 2009

Facts, Fallacies and Bigots

August 25, 2009

The following letter appeared in a newspaper in response to a previous letter-writer
who criticized Islam. The letter is an excellent example of authoritarian thinking.

We find otherwise good people become bigots when they discuss Islam. They
judge Islam by its extremists. Unfortunately, Islamophobia is the last remaining
acceptable prejudice.

When they say that Islam abuses women, murders apostates and hates outsiders,
they are talking about a counterfeit Islam. We find such hatred amongst both
Jews and Christians as well.

One Muslim writer pointed out that there is enough in the Koran for global
holy war. But there is also enough there for people of a peaceful mindset
to discover a path to enlightenment and peace. There is bad material in the
Hebrew Scriptures and the New Testament as well. But we can also find sublime
uplifting passages.

Our spiritual work, as brothers of the Abrahamic faith, is to combat ugly
anti-Muslim sentiments and make it socially intolerable.

Signed: Rabbi …

First things first. There is not one single fact about Islam in the entire
letter. We know this because anything that relates to the doctrine of Islam
includes the words: Allah or Mohammed. Instead of facts, the writer substitutes
his authoritarian reasoning and the opinion of "one Muslim writer",
not Mohammed. He declares from his high moral ground the judgment that anyone
who criticizes Islam is a bigot. Why? He decrees it. Evidence? Facts? No need
for those when you have the authority to make decrees.

He uses the word "counterfeit". And what is the standard to determine
counterfeit from the real deal? Simple, the one and only standard of Islam is
the Koran and the Sunna. Let's use that standard. For those who enjoy fact-based
logic: Does Islam abuse women? Let's start with the Koran:

Koran 4:34 Allah has made men superior to women because men spend their wealth
to support them. Therefore, virtuous women are obedient, and they are to guard
their unseen parts as Allah has guarded them. As for women whom you fear will
rebel, admonish them first, and then send them to a separate bed, and then beat
them. But if they are obedient after that, then do nothing further; surely Allah
is exalted and great!

Now let us turn to Mohammed as found the Hadith (Mohammed's traditions). Mohammed's
words and actions (Sunna) are half of Islam. If Mohammed did it, then it not
extremist, by definition.

Abu Dawud 11, 2142: Mohammed said: A man will not be asked as to why he beat
his wife.

This hadith equates camels, slaves and women.

Abu Dawud 11, 2155: Mohammed said: If one of you marries a woman or buys
a slave, he should say: "O Allah, I ask You for the good in her, and in
the disposition You have given her; I take refuge in You from the evil in her,
and in the disposition You have given her." When he buys a camel, he should
take hold of the top of its hump and say the same kind of thing.

More advice about slaves and women:

Bukhari 7,62,132: The Prophet said, "None of you should flog his wife
as he flogs a slave and then have sexual intercourse with her in the last part
of the day."

A statistical summary is revealing. Here is a table that summarizes all of
the sentences and verses about women that can be found in the Koran and the
Hadith by Bukhari. Each sentence was judged as to whether the woman was superior
to men, equal to men or inferior. All of the superior sentences were about women
as mothers, the equality sentences were about being judged equally on Judgment
Day. And what is one of the things a woman is judged on? How well she pleased
her husband.

	Superior	Equal	Inferior	Neutral
Number of verses and hadiths	7	8	157	47
Percentage based on superior and inferior	4%	5%	91%	Not included in calculations

Equality of Sexes in Hadith and Koran

Does Islam murder apostates (those who leave Islam)? Let us ask what the Sunna
of Mohammed is.

Bukhari 9, 83, 37: […] This news reached Allah's Apostle , so he sent
(men) to follow their traces and they were captured and brought (to the Prophet).
He then ordered to cut their hands and feet, and their eyes were branded with
heated pieces of iron, and then he threw them in the sun till they died."
I said, "What can be worse than what those people did? They deserted Islam,
committed murder and theft."

Bukhari 9, 84, 57: […] I would have killed them according to the statement
of Allah's Apostle, 'Whoever changed his Islamic religion, then kill him.'"

Bukhari 9, 84, 58: […] Behold: There was a fettered man beside Abu
Muisa. Mu'adh asked, "Who is this (man)?" Abu Muisa said, "He
was a Jew and became a Muslim and then reverted back to Judaism." Then
Abu Muisa requested Mu'adh to sit down but Mu'adh said, "I will not sit
down till he has been killed. This is the judgment of Allah and His Apostle
(for such cases) and repeated it thrice. Then Abu Musa ordered that the man
be killed, and he was killed. […]

It is Sunna to kill apostates. Islamic doctrine says to kill apostates. As
an aside, when Mohammed, died the next caliph, Abu Bakr, killed apostates for
two years because many Muslims wanted to quit. Abu Bakr persuaded the survivors
to be contented Muslims.

Does Islam hate outsiders? Let us turn to the Koran and consider a word introduced
and defined by the Koran. The word is kafir (unbeliever), the ultimate outsider.
More that half of the Koran is about kafirs. The only good verses about kafirs
are "abrogated" later in the Koran. Allah hates kafirs and plots against
them.

Koran 40:35 They who dispute the signs of Allah [kafirs] without authority
having reached them are greatly hated by Allah and the believers. So Allah seals
up every arrogant, disdainful heart.

Koran 86:15 They plot and scheme against you [Mohammed], and I plot and
scheme against them. Therefore, deal calmly with the kafirs and leave them alone
for a while.

Kafirs can be tortured, mocked, robbed, enslaved and raped. Kafir is the worst
word in the human language.

The rabbi grapples with the duality of the Koran in his paragraph about the
good and the bad in the Koran. He makes the usual argument about "it all
depends on the interpretation." This drive for interpretation is an attempt
to eliminate the contradictory nature of the Koran. The Koran is filled with
contradictions at all levels, and this was pointed out to Mohammed by the Meccans
of his day. The Koran uses the principle of abrogation to resolve these contradictions.
The later verse is better than the earlier verse.

But since everything in the Koran is the exact word of Allah and Allah is perfect
and cannot lie, then every verse of the Koran is true, even if it is contradictory.
This violates our logic so we try to decide which side is the truth. But both
sides are true in dualistic logic. The Koran is dualistic document and Islam
is a dualistic ideology. The answer to the question: "which side is it?"
is always--all of the above. That is the genius of Islam. It can have it both
ways, and this confuses the kafirs.

Now to the idea of: "brothers in the Abrahamic faith." Let us look
to Mohammed for the relationship between Muslims and their Jewish brothers.
At first, Mohammed proved his validity by the fact that his angel was Gabriel,
the angel of the prophets of the Jews. Therefore, he was of the same prophetic
linage. Since there were no Jews in Mecca to deny him, the idea worked.

When he went to Medina, which was half Jewish, the rabbis told him he was no
prophet in the lineage of the Jews. No one contradicted Mohammed and as a result,
three years later, there was not a single Jew left in Medina-they were annihilated.
Then he attacked the Jews of Khaybar and made them dhimmis after he had killed,
tortured, raped and robbed them. On his deathbed he condemned the Jews and Christians
to be banished from Arabia. There are no Jews in Arabia today.

That is the Sunna. That is Islam. And that is the way Islam has treated the
Jews and Christians ever since-as dhimmis. Dhimmis are kafirs who serve Islam
by submitting and laboring for Islam. If the dhimmi is subservient enough, Islam
will be kind. There are no brothers of Abraham. Just dhimmis to Mohammed! The
root of the problem with Israel is that Israelis refuse to act like dhimmis.

We need to address one last bit of sophistry. He subtly shifts the argument
about Islam to Muslims. Muslims are people and as such vary. There are 1.5 billion
varieties of Muslims, but only one source of Islam. We need to stick to the
study of Islam and leave Muslims out of it. You can prove anything about Islam
if you use Muslim-ology; just find the Muslim who says what you want and quote
him.

It would seem that before a spiritual leader (although this writer is a Jew,
his arguments do not differ a whit from any pious dhimmi Christian pastor) takes
on the task of calling those who use critical thought bigots, a better task
would be to seek the truth of Islamic ideology. The truth of Islam is found
in the Koran, the Sunna (Sira and Hadith) and Islam's political history. As
a spiritual leader, once you have mastered those texts, you can speak to the
issue. Until then, play the role of the student and stop referring to those
with knowledge as bigots.

This has been an exercise in fact-based rational thought; compare it to his
authoritarian thought and assertions.