Monday, November 11, 2013

Eye on Iran: Iran Balked at Language of Draft Nuclear Deal, Western Diplomats Say







For continuing coverage follow us on Twitter and join our Facebook group.
  
Top Stories

NYT:
"As Secretary of State John Kerry and foreign ministers from other world powers sought to hammer out an interim agreement to constrain Iran's nuclear program, the Iranian government's insistence on formal recognition of its 'right' to enrich uranium emerged as a major obstacle, diplomats said Sunday. In long hours of closed-door discussions, Western and Iranian negotiators haggled over the language of a possible agreement. Toward the end of a marathon session, some diplomats believed that only a handful of words appeared to separate the two sides. But the dispute over enrichment rights, among other differences, meant that the talks ended not with the breakthrough that many had hoped for, but with only a promise that lower-level negotiators would meet here in 10 days for more discussions. Many reports have ascribed the failure of the talks to France's insistence that any agreement put tight restriction on a heavy-water plant that Iran is building, which can produce plutonium. But while France took a harder line than its partners on some issues, a senior American official said it was the Iranian delegation that balked at completing an interim agreement, saying that it had to engage in additional consultations in Tehran before proceeding further... Defending his negotiating strategy, Mr. Kerry insisted Sunday that the agreement to freeze Iran's nuclear program that he was seeking would be in Israel's interest. 'We are not blind, and I don't think we are stupid,' Mr. Kerry said on 'Meet the Press.'" http://t.uani.com/18ksl5I

AFP: "US Secretary of State John Kerry on Monday defended moves to strike a nuclear deal with Iran, saying it would protect Israel and America's Gulf allies, while stressing Tehran had balked... 'Our hope is that in the next months we can find an agreement that meets everyone's standards,' Kerry told reporters in Abu Dhabi. 'The P5+1 was unified on Saturday when we presented our proposal to the Iranians... But Iran couldn't take it, at that particular moment they weren't able to accept,' he said." http://t.uani.com/1gD5Cu3

AFP: "President Hassan Rouhani said on Sunday that Iran will not abandon its nuclear rights, including uranium enrichment, media reported a day after a fresh round of talks with world powers. 'There are red lines that must not be crossed,' Rouhani told the conservative-dominated parliament in remarks quoted by the ISNA news agency. 'The rights of the Iranian nation and our national interests are a red line. So are nuclear rights under the framework of international regulations, which include enrichment on Iranian soil,' he said... Rouhani said Iran would 'not bow to threats from any power', while also insisting that the sanctions targeting its ailing economy had not forced Tehran to the negotiating table. 'We have practically and verbally told the negotiating sides that threats, sanctions, humiliation and discrimination will never produce a result,' he said." http://t.uani.com/1hywWe7

Reuters: "Iran will grant U.N. inspectors 'managed access' to a uranium mine and a heavy water plant within three months as part of a deal agreed on Monday aimed at improving transparency in the Islamic state's disputed nuclear programme. It was signed by U.N. nuclear agency chief Yukiya Amano in Tehran after Iran and six world powers failed in broader diplomatic talks in Geneva at the weekend to clinch an agreement to help allay Western fears that Iran may be seeking a nuclear weapons capability. Tehran denies the charge. Under the accord with the IAEA, Iran will also provide information about planned new research reactors and sites for future nuclear power plants, as well as clarify earlier statements about additional uranium enrichment facilities. The IAEA and Iran have agreed 'to strengthen their cooperation and dialogue aimed at ensuring the exclusively peaceful nature of Iran's nuclear programme,' a joint statement distributed in Vienna said. 'It is foreseen that Iran's cooperation will include providing the IAEA with timely information about its nuclear facilities and in regard to the implementation of transparency measures. Activities will proceed in a step-by-step manner,' it said. An annex to the agreement listed six first steps to be implemented by Iran over the next three months, including access to the Gchine uranium mine and the Arak heavy water production plant, which the IAEA has repeatedly asked for." http://t.uani.com/19W399C
Election Repression ToolkitNuclear Negotiations

AFP: "Conservative US leaders, fond of finger-pointing at France in recent years, lavished praise on Paris Sunday for blocking an agreement between Western powers and Iran over Tehran's nuclear program. 'Vive la France!' tweeted Senator John McCain, an outspoken voice on national security issues. 'France had the courage to prevent a bad nuclear agreement with Iran,' he said, after the weekend announcement that no agreement had been reached between the United States, China, Russia, Britain, France and Germany, known as the P5+1. During three days of intense negotiations in Geneva, France repeatedly voiced concerns over various points in a possible deal and its lack of guarantees, a position that had Iran calling it a negotiations spoiled sport. 'Thank God for France and thank God for push back,' said hawkish Senator Lindsey Graham on CNN's 'State of the Union' show. 'The French are becoming very good leaders in the Mideast,' Graham said, also suggesting he would be in favor of more sanctions against Iran." http://t.uani.com/1iY67LZ

Reuters: "A Twitter account Iran experts believe is run by the office of Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei reiterated criticism of France on Sunday after Paris expressed reservations about a proposed deal to end a dispute over Tehran's nuclear program. A message posted in English on the account @khamenei_ir said: 'French officials have been openly hostile towards the Iranian nation over the past few years; this is an imprudent and inept move.' A second tweet said: 'A wise man, particularly a wise politician, should never have the motivation to turn a neutral entity into an enemy.'" http://t.uani.com/1fv4ENm

Reuters: "U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry said on Monday Washington was not engaged in a race to complete talks with Iran on its nuclear program and vowed to defend Washington's regional allies against any threats. Speaking at a news conference with United Arab Emirates (UAE) Foreign Minister Sheikh Abdullah bin Zayed al-Nahayan in Abu Dhabi, Kerry also praised the Syrian opposition's decision to participate in a proposed peace conference as 'a big step forward'. 'This is not a race to complete just any agreement,' Kerry said, adding: 'Through diplomacy we have an absolute responsibility to pursue an agreement.'" http://t.uani.com/1cf8szH

Reuters: "Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu took his case against a nuclear accord with Iran directly to the U.S. public on Sunday, denouncing 'a very bad deal' that he feared the Obama administration was pursuing... On CBS television's Face the Nation on Sunday, Netanyahu said the proposed interim agreement, as 'described to us by American sources', would have allowed Iran to maintain its capability to enrich material for nuclear bombs... In Jerusalem, Netanyahu urged hundreds of supporters attending an assembly of the quasi-governmental Jewish Agency, many of them from the United States, to help him avert what he called a 'bad and dangerous deal' emerging with Iran... 'There are many Arab leaders in the region who are saying this is a very bad deal for the region and for the world,' Netanyahu said on Sunday on CBS. 'And you know when you have the Arabs and the Israelis speaking in one voice, it doesn't happen very often, I think it's worth paying attention to it.'" http://t.uani.com/1iY9y5m

Sanctions

Reuters: "U.S. lawmakers said on Sunday they aimed to tighten sanctions on Iran to prevent Washington giving away too much in a deal on Tehran's nuclear program that diplomats said was still possible despite the failure of high-level weekend talks. Their comments reflected widespread Congressional skepticism about a rapprochement between Iran and world powers and coincided with renewed lobbying from Israel against a proposal it sees as leaving open a danger Iran could build a nuclear bomb. Tehran denies harboring any such ambition... The Senate Foreign Relations Committee will move ahead with additional sanctions this week to keep the pressure on Iran as talks continue, said Democratic Senator Bob Menendez, the committee's Democratic chairman. 'My concern here is that we seem to want the deal almost more than the Iranians,' Menendez said on ABC's 'This Week.'" http://t.uani.com/1bjqAXs

Reuters: "Iran's fuel oil exports will plunge to as little as a third of previous levels over the next few months as winter demand forces the country to divert the product to its own power plants, according to a National Iranian Oil Company (NIOC) source. The fall means additional revenue lost to the OPEC member, which is already down billions of petrodollars a month due to tough Western sanctions that have halved its crude exports and crippled its economy by choking Tehran's biggest money stream... Sanctions have made it difficult to track Iranian fuel oil flows. The country typically exports about 600,000 tonnes of fuel oil a month, about 130,000 barrels per day, most of which heads to China and the rest of Asia, trade sources said. Exports of the heavy fuel have reached as much as 1 million tonnes in some months. But the lower volumes that started at end-September and are expected to last until early January will drop monthly shipments to about 200,000-300,000 tonnes, the NIOC source said. Iran's low density, low sulphur fuel oil is suitable both as a feedstock for the smaller, independent refineries in China, often called teapots, and for blending with heavier grades." http://t.uani.com/19duz6p

Domestic Politics

Reuters: "An unidentified attacker shot dead an Iranian deputy minister of industry in Tehran on Sunday, the state news agency IRNA reported, in what appeared the first reported killing of a senior central government official in years. Safdar Rahmat Abadi was shot in the head and chest as he got into his car in the east of the capital, IRNA said, quoting witnesses as saying the attack occurred at about 7:50 p.m. (1620 GMT). 'Investigations show that two shots were fired from inside the vehicle,' the agency quoted a police official as saying. 'That two shells were found inside the car shows a strong likelihood that the assailant was inside the car and in conversation with Mr Abadi. There was no sign of struggle at the scene of the killing.'" http://t.uani.com/1hytcJD

AFP: "Iran's Defence Minister Hossein Dehqan on Saturday inaugurated the production line of an anti-missile system dubbed the Sayyad-2 (Hunter 2), media reported. 'In order to counter aerial attack, we have put the production of the Sayyad-2 missile system on the agenda,' Dehqan said on state television during the inauguration ceremony. 'This solid-fuel missile system is able to destroy different kinds of cruise missiles, bombers, drones and helicopters,' he added... In September, the military paraded missiles with a nominal range of 2,000 kilometres (1,250 miles) that could theoretically hit Israeli and US military targets in the region." http://t.uani.com/19cot6f

AFP: "Air pollution has forced Iranian authorities to close elementary schools and kindergartens in Tehran province for three days from Sunday, the state broadcaster said. Schools had already been closed due to pollution on Sunday, while government agencies were to shorten working hours on Monday and Tuesday as pollution has reached alarming levels. Sunday's decision to extend the school closure for more two days was made by a crisis committee on air pollution, the broadcaster said... With four of its cities among the world's 10 most polluted, other parts of the country also struggle with pollution. In 2012, air pollution contributed to nearly 4,500 premature deaths in Tehran alone and nearly 80,000 across the country, according to figures by the health ministry. Dozens of people were hospitalised last week in the southwestern city of Ahvaz, and thousands rushed to get medical assistance as pollution levels reached dangerous levels." http://t.uani.com/HP7t0p

Foreign Affairs

Reuters: "Britain said on Monday it had revived diplomatic relations with Iran and appointed a non-resident charge d'affaires, two years after an angry mob ransacked the British embassy in Tehran... Britain's Foreign Office said Ajay Sharma, currently the head of the ministry's Iran department, would take up the post immediately and hoped to visit Tehran this month. 'I am very much looking forward to renewing direct UK contact with the Iranian government and society,' Sharma said in a statement. 'This is very much in the interests of both our countries.' Iran's Mehr news agency said Tehran had appointed Mohammad Hassan Habibollah as charge d'affaires to Britain." http://t.uani.com/17OWtMc
Opinion & Analysis

WSJ Editorial: "We never thought we'd say this, but thank heaven for French foreign-policy exceptionalism. At least for the time being, François Hollande's Socialist government has saved the West from a deal that would all but guarantee that Iran becomes a nuclear power. While the negotiating details still aren't fully known, the French made clear Saturday that they objected to a nuclear agreement that British Prime Minister David Cameron and President Barack Obama were all too eager to sign. These two leaders remind no one, least of all the Iranians, of Tony Blair, Margaret Thatcher, Ronald Reagan or George W. Bush. That left the French to protect against a historic security blunder, with Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius declaring in an interview with French radio that while France still hopes for an agreement with Tehran, it won't accept a 'sucker's deal.' And that's exactly what seems to have been on the table as part of a 'first-step agreement' good for six months as the parties negotiated a final deal. Tehran would be allowed to continue enriching uranium, continue manufacturing centrifuges, and continue building a plutonium reactor near the city of Arak. Iran would also get immediate sanctions relief and the unfreezing of as much as $50 billion in oil revenues-no small deliverance for a regime whose annual oil revenues barely topped $95 billion in 2011. In return the West would get Iranian promises. There is a promise not to activate the Arak reactor, a promise not to use its most advanced centrifuges to enrich uranium or to install new ones, a promise to stop enriching uranium to 20%, which is near-weapons' grade, and to convert its existing stockpile into uranium oxide (a process that is reversible). What Iran has not promised to do is abide by the Additional Protocol of the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty (NPT), which imposes additional reporting requirements on Iran and allows U.N. inspectors to conduct short-notice inspections of nuclear facilities. The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) has complained for years that Iran has refused to answer its questions fully or provide inspectors with access to all of its facilities. IAEA inspectors have been barred from visiting Arak since August 2011.  In other words, the deal gives Iran immediate, if incomplete, sanctions relief and allows it to keep its nuclear infrastructure intact and keep expanding it at a slightly slower pace. And the deal contains no meaningful mechanisms for verifying compliance... The negotiators plan to resume talks on November 20, and France will be under enormous pressure to go along with a deal. We hope Messrs. Hollande and Fabius hold firm, and the U.S. Congress could help by strengthening sanctions and passing a resolution insisting that any agreement with Iran must include no uranium enrichment, the dismantling of the Arak plutonium project and all centrifuges, and intrusive, on-demand inspections. Anything less means that Iran is merely looking to con the West into easing sanctions even as it can restart its program whenever it likes." http://t.uani.com/17NB9qn

Reuters Special Report: "A Reuters investigation details a key to the supreme leader's power: a little-known organization created to help the poor that morphed into a business juggernaut worth tens of billions of dollars. The 82-year-old Iranian woman keeps the documents that upended her life in an old suitcase near her bed. She removes them carefully and peers at the tiny Persian script. There's the court order authorizing the takeover of her children's three Tehran apartments in a multi-story building the family had owned for years. There's the letter announcing the sale of one of the units. And there's the notice demanding she pay rent on her own apartment on the top floor. Pari Vahdat-e-Hagh ultimately lost her property. It was taken by an organization that is controlled by the most powerful man in Iran: Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei. She now lives alone in a cramped, three-room apartment in Europe, thousands of miles from Tehran. The Persian name of the organization that hounded her for years is 'Setad Ejraiye Farmane Hazrate Emam' - Headquarters for Executing the Order of the Imam. The name refers to an edict signed by the Islamic Republic's first leader, Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, shortly before his death in 1989. His order spawned a new entity to manage and sell properties abandoned in the chaotic years after the 1979 Islamic Revolution. Setad has become one of the most powerful organizations in Iran, though many Iranians, and the wider world, know very little about it. In the past six years, it has morphed into a business juggernaut that now holds stakes in nearly every sector of Iranian industry, including finance, oil, telecommunications, the production of birth-control pills and even ostrich farming. The organization's total worth is difficult to pinpoint because of the secrecy of its accounts. But Setad's holdings of real estate, corporate stakes and other assets total about $95 billion, Reuters has calculated. That estimate is based on an analysis of statements by Setad officials, data from the Tehran Stock Exchange and company websites, and information from the U.S. Treasury Department. Just one person controls that economic empire - Khamenei. As Iran's top cleric, he has the final say on all governmental matters. His purview includes his nation's controversial nuclear program, which was the subject of intense negotiations between Iranian and international diplomats in Geneva that ended Sunday without an agreement. It is Khamenei who will set Iran's course in the nuclear talks and other recent efforts by the new president, Hassan Rouhani, to improve relations with Washington. The supreme leader's acolytes praise his spartan lifestyle, and point to his modest wardrobe and a threadbare carpet in his Tehran home. Reuters found no evidence that Khamenei is tapping Setad to enrich himself. But Setad has empowered him. Through Setad, Khamenei has at his disposal financial resources whose value rivals the holdings of the shah, the Western-backed monarch who was overthrown in 1979. How Setad came into those assets also mirrors how the deposed monarchy obtained much of its fortune - by confiscating real estate. A six-month Reuters investigation has found that Setad built its empire on the systematic seizure of thousands of properties belonging to ordinary Iranians: members of religious minorities like Vahdat-e-Hagh, who is Baha'i, as well as Shi'ite Muslims, business people and Iranians living abroad. Setad has amassed a giant portfolio of real estate by claiming in Iranian courts, sometimes falsely, that the properties are abandoned. The organization now holds a court-ordered monopoly on taking property in the name of the supreme leader, and regularly sells the seized properties at auction or seeks to extract payments from the original owners. The supreme leader also oversaw the creation of a body of legal rulings and executive orders that enabled and safeguarded Setad's asset acquisitions. 'No supervisory organization can question its property,' said Naghi Mahmoudi, an Iranian lawyer who left Iran in 2010 and now lives in Germany. Khamenei's grip on Iran's politics and its military forces has been apparent for years. The investigation into Setad shows that there is a third dimension to his power: economic might. The revenue stream generated by Setad helps explain why Khamenei has not only held on for 24 years but also in some ways has more control than even his revered predecessor. Setad gives him the financial means to operate independently of parliament and the national budget, insulating him from Iran's messy factional infighting. Washington has acknowledged Setad's importance. In June, the Treasury Department imposed sanctions on Setad and some of its corporate holdings, calling the organization 'a massive network of front companies hiding assets on behalf of ... Iran's leadership.' The companies generate billions of dollars in revenue a year, the department stated, but it did not offer a detailed accounting." http://t.uani.com/1i16CqZ

UANI Advisory Board Member Irwin Cotler in JPost: "However, while negotiations will clearly focus on Iran's nuclear program - and on economic sanctions that may be relaxed in exchange for Iranian concessions on the nuclear front - the United States and its allies must ensure that nuclear negotiations do not overshadow - let alone sanitize - the massive domestic repression in Iran. Indeed, when the US negotiated an arms control agreement with the Soviet Union in 1975, it did not turn a blind eye to the USSR's human rights abuses; instead, the Helsinki Final Act linked the security, economics, and human rights 'baskets,' with human rights emerging as the most transformative of the three. Negotiations with Iran should replicate this approach. What follows is an inventory of serious human rights abuses in Iran, and a corresponding set of queries that will serve as a litmus test for the authenticity of Rouhani's commitment to justice and human rights for the Iranian people." http://t.uani.com/1aNHwdF

UANI Sanctions Legislation & Media Advisor David Peyman interviewed in the LA Jewish Journal: "With the recent talks between Iran and six of the world's major powers on the Iranian regime's pursuit on nuclear weapons, countless Jewish and non-Jewish groups in the U.S. are calling for local and state officials to turn up the pressure on the Iranian regime by enforcing tough federal sanctions. Specifically, the New York-based 'United Against Nuclear Iran' (UANI) has worked with the American Jewish Committee (AJC) and other Southern California groups to call on L.A. mayor Eric Garcetti to ban ships that have docked in Iranian ports from docking in the Port of Los Angeles. With this move activists believe the Iranian regime will be squeezed economically even further to stop their nuclear weapons pursuit...I recently had a chance to chat with David Peyman, an Iranian Jewish activist and senior advisor to UANI about the calls for Iran sanctions to be imposed on the Port of Los Angeles. The following is a portion of our conversation." http://t.uani.com/1iYeaID

Eye on Iran is a periodic news summary from United Against Nuclear Iran (UANI) a program of the American Coalition Against Nuclear Iran, Inc., a tax-exempt organization under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code. Eye on Iran is not intended as a comprehensive media clips summary but rather a selection of media elements with discreet analysis in a PDA friendly format. For more information please email Press@UnitedAgainstNuclearIran.com

United Against Nuclear Iran (UANI) is a non-partisan, broad-based coalition that is united in a commitment to prevent Iran from fulfilling its ambition to become a regional super-power possessing nuclear weapons.  UANI is an issue-based coalition in which each coalition member will have its own interests as well as the collective goal of advancing an Iran free of nuclear weapons.





No comments:

Post a Comment