Monday, May 12, 2014

Eye on Iran: Negotiations with Iran over Nuclear Program Still Face a Major Hurdle








Join UANI  
 Like us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter View our videos on YouTube
   
Top Stories

LAT: "Three months into intense international negotiations over Iran's disputed nuclear development program, Tehran's team has surprised almost everybody with its apparent eagerness for a deal... Yet President Hassan Rouhani's government is moving away from the United States and its allies on an issue that may be the most important of all... Put simply, the six world powers want Iran to curtail enrichment of uranium to limit any bomb-making potential. They want Tehran to cut its 19,000 uranium-enriching centrifuges to a few thousand. Tehran, however, is insisting on vastly expanding capacity by adding thousands more centrifuges for what it says is strictly civilian energy purposes. With talks scheduled to resume this week in Vienna, the dispute looms as the biggest threat to the comprehensive nuclear deal the two sides are trying to complete by a July 20 deadline. Iran's demand to boost enrichment capacity 'would be a show-stopper,' said Robert Einhorn, who was a member of President Obama's inner circle of nuclear advisors until late last year and is now with the Brookings Institution. 'There won't be an agreement.' ... Gary Samore, Obama's nonproliferation advisor from 2009 to 2013, said he believes the Iranians are not bluffing, though they may ease their demands later in negotiations. 'I think this is their real position,' said Samore, executive director for research at the Harvard Kennedy School's Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs... Samore said he doesn't expect the two sides to resolve these disputes and complete the deal by mid-July. But he said they may make enough progress to convince both Congress and hard-liners in Tehran that negotiations should continue six more months, as the interim agreement allows." http://t.uani.com/1jahx4g

AFP: "Iran will not accept 'nuclear apartheid' but is willing to offer more transparency over its atomic activities, President Hassan Rouhani said on Sunday ahead of new talks with world powers. Iran and the P5+1 group of nations will start hammering out a draft accord Tuesday aimed at ending a decade-long stand-off over suspicions that the Islamic republic is concealing military objectives. 'We have nothing to put on the table and offer to them but transparency. That's it. Our nuclear technology is not up for negotiation,' Rouhani, referring to the West, said in remarks broadcast on state television. 'Iran will not retreat one step in the field of nuclear technology... we will not accept nuclear apartheid,' he said." http://t.uani.com/1guRb7g

Reuters: "Iran's Supreme Leader described as 'stupid and idiotic' Western expectations for his country to curb its missile development, striking a defiant tone ahead of a fresh round of nuclear talks. Ayatollah Ali Khamenei called on Iran's Revolutionary Guards to mass produce missiles and said the nuclear negotiations were not the place to discuss Tehran's defense program or to solve the problem of sanctions damaging the Iranian economy. 'They expect us to limit our missile program while they constantly threaten Iran with military action,' Khamenei was quoted as telling the IRNA news agency while on a visit to an aeronautics fair held by the Revolutionary Guards. 'So this is a stupid, idiotic expectation ... The revolutionary guards should definitely carry out their program and not be satisfied with the present level. They should mass produce. This is a main duty of all military officials.'" http://t.uani.com/1g1kDqw

Guardian: "Iran and its close ally President Bashar al-Assad have won the war in Syria, and the US-orchestrated campaign in support of the opposition's attempt to topple the Syrian regime has failed, senior Iranian officials have told the Guardian. In a series of interviews in Tehran, top figures who shape Iranian foreign policy said the west's strategy in Syria had merely encouraged radicals, caused chaos and ultimately backfired, with government forces now on the front foot. 'We have won in Syria,' said Alaeddin Borujerdi, chairman of the Iranian parliament's national security and foreign policy committee and an influential government insider. 'The regime will stay. The Americans have lost it.'" http://t.uani.com/1uU6kZi
       
Nuclear Program & Negotiations

Reuters: "President Hassan Rouhani said on Sunday he wanted Iran to do a better job of explaining its nuclear program to prevent 'evil-minded' people misleading world opinion, two days before Tehran resumes talks with world powers on its disputed atomic activity... 'If one engages in a technological endeavor but is not doing good legal and political work, then the enemy might come up with a fictional excuse to cause trouble for you,' he said. The Islamic Republic's leaders normally use the term 'the enemy' to refer to the United States and Israel. 'If you don't have good public relations and are not able to communicate well, then you might find other evil-minded people misleading world public opinion,' Rouhani said. 'So our effort today is to even out our efforts on multiple levels ... We don't want to retreat one step from our pursuit of technology, but we want to take a step forward on the political front.' ... Rouhani said Iran if it so chose could resume enrichment of uranium gas to a fissile purity of 20 percent - its most sensitive nuclear activity because it is a relatively short technical step away from the level required for nuclear weapons. 'We wanted to tell the world that our activities are moving in the right direction: If we say we can enrich to 3.5 percent, we can do it. If necessary we will do (it to) 20 percent,' he said." http://t.uani.com/1mhlrb8

AP: "Iran's president said Sunday his country would not surrender what it considers its right to nuclear development in upcoming talks with world powers, but that it would be 'transparent' in negotiations over the contested program... 'If the world seeks good relations with Iran, it should choose the way of surrendering to Iran's rights, respecting the Iranian nation and praising Iranian scientists,' Rouhani said in the speech, which was aired live by state television. 'The Iranian nation has never been after a weapon of mass destruction since it does not see it as legitimate,' Rouhani said. 'We do not have anything on the table to submit to others except transparency,' he added." http://t.uani.com/1jSbIqW

Reuters: "Iran's attempts to illicitly procure materials for its disputed nuclear and missile programs appear to have slowed down as it pursues talks on a long-term accord with world powers, a U.N. expert panel said in a confidential report seen by Reuters. The U.N. Panel of Experts, who monitor compliance with the Security Council's sanctions regime on Iran, presented this conclusion cautiously, suggesting it was also possible Tehran has simply learned to outsmart security and intelligence services in its pursuit of sensitive components and materials. The report cited 'a decrease in the number of detected attempts by Iran to procure items for prohibited programs, and related seizures, since mid-2013 ... It is possible that this decrease reflects the new political environment in Iran and diplomatic progress towards a comprehensive solution.' ... But, the report cautioned, 'this may be a function of more sophisticated procurement strategies on the part of Iran, which has developed methods of concealing procurement, while expanding prohibited activities. Such methods can also be used by Iran to procure and finance legitimate trade, which further complicates the efforts of states to identify illicit procurement.' The report added that Iran had 'also demonstrated a growing capability to produce key items indigenously'. Among sensitive dual-use items Iran has pursued abroad over the years have been aluminum, carbon fiber and special valves." http://t.uani.com/1skE3XK

Reuters: "The U.N. nuclear watchdog plans talks with Iran on Monday ahead of a May 15 deadline for the country to implement a series of measures that could allay concern about its nuclear program that the West fears may have military goals. News of the meeting came after diplomatic sources told Reuters on Friday that the International Atomic Energy Agency was seeking further clarification from Iran about one of those steps, concerning information about detonators that can help set off a nuclear device and Tehran is believed to have developed. Iran says it has already implemented the seven steps agreed by the two sides - including access to two uranium sites - but the sources suggested the IAEA still wanted more information about the so-called Explosive Bridge Wire (EBW) detonators. How Iran responds to questions about its development and need of this type of equipment is seen as an important test of its willingness to cooperate fully with an IAEA investigation into suspected atomic bomb research by the country... IAEA spokeswoman Gill Tudor said in an email on Sunday that the meeting would take place in Vienna but gave no detail." http://t.uani.com/1g1hBm8

Guardian: "The Ukraine crisis has strengthened Iran's hand in its nuclear talks and other dealings with the west by reminding European countries and the Obama administration of its potential as a major alternative energy supplier if Russia cannot be relied upon, officials and analysts in Tehran say. But even as it attempts to play the Russia card, the government of President Hassan Rouhani is simultaneously stressing closer bilateral ties with Vladimir Putin's Kremlin as a means of mitigating the impact of US, EU and UN economic sanctions, imposed in the still-unresolved row over Iran's nuclear programme. 'The western countries are imposing sanctions on Russia [after its annexation of Crimea]. Now Russia is the bad guy,' said Amir Mohebbian, a government adviser. 'This has made the situation better for Iran's nuclear negotiators. Time is on our side. If we sit here long enough, it will all come to Iran.' It was not for Iran to say who was right or wrong in Ukraine, said Mohammad Marandi, an international relations expert at Tehran University. 'But of course if Iran is no longer under sanctions, the Europeans would have many more choices regarding energy. At the same time, if the sanctions continue, Rouhani may move closer to Russia and China.'" http://t.uani.com/1skJq9r

WSJ: "U.S. allies in Europe see an added bonus to a comprehensive nuclear agreement being reached with Iran: a potential partner in the energy war against Russian President Vladimir Putin... Western energy companies are expressing growing interest in returning to Iran as a result of the nuclear talks. And European countries, wary of Russia's military moves into Ukraine, see renewed Iranian energy supplies as a way to undercut Mr. Putin's ability to use oil and gas as a weapon against the European Union and many former Soviet states. 'It would be good for Iranian energy to flow back into Europe,' said Georgian Defense Minister Irakli Alasania in an interview last week... 'The Russians don't want Iranian gas going to Europe,' said an Iranian businessman who advises President Hasan Rouhani's government on economic issues. 'The Iranians think [the U.S. and Europe] should play that card.'" http://t.uani.com/1hHfXkR

Military Matters

AFP: "Iran said on Sunday it has succeeded in copying a US drone it captured in December 2011, with state television broadcasting images apparently showing the replicated aircraft. Tehran captured the US RQ-170 Sentinel in 2011 while it was in its airspace, apparently on a mission to spy on the country's nuclear sites, media in the United States reported. 'Our engineers succeeded in breaking the drone's secrets and copying them. It will soon take a test flight,' an officer said in the footage." http://t.uani.com/1ge3xGz

Human Rights

AP: "Iranian authorities have detained a reformist journalist on security charges, the official news agency reported Sunday. IRNA quoted the journalist's attorney, Giti Pourfazel, as saying that a court Saturday charged Serajeddin Mirdamadi of plotting against Iran's ruling clerics and ordered his temporary detention. Pourfazel said Mirdamadi stood accused of spreading lies against the government earlier this year but was freed on bail." http://t.uani.com/1guSwuP

Al-Monitor: "Prosecutor-General Gholam Hossein Mohseni-Ejei said on May 6 during a meeting of the High Council for Human Rights in Iran, 'Unfortunately, the high number of executions in this country is related to drugs smuggling and the heavy penalties of this phenomenon. If within the existing laws we can review it in a way that we help the intelligence officials to punish the leaders of these smuggling networks, and for the rest we reconsider [their punishment], the goals of the system can better be realized with respect to drugs.' While there are many caveats to Ejei's statement, it is noteworthy that a figure with his background would make this suggestion publicly at this type of session." http://t.uani.com/1skIGB2

ICHRI: "Imprisoned student activist Maryam Shafipour has developed a severe reaction from a medication incorrectly prescribed for her for three months by prison doctors for a lymphatic condition. Prison authorities have refused to allow her to see a specialist. An informed source who wished to remain anonymous told the Campaign that Mehdi Khodabakhshi, Supervising Assistant Prosecutor in Evin Prison, told Shafipour's family that the refusal to allow proper treatment was in reprisal for the publicity about Shafipour's detention. The error in the medication was discovered when she showed the pills to doctors at Shohada Hospital in Tajrish, northern Tehran, where she was being treated for a bleeding stomach." http://t.uani.com/1jS3yPi

Domestic Politics

Reuters: "Payment problems are disrupting commercial food cargoes to Iran, with hundreds of thousands of tons of grain and sugar stuck in transit, as Western banking sanctions complicate deals and trade financiers scale back exposure... Several international trade sources, with knowledge of deals that have been affected, told Reuters that ships carrying cargoes of grain, including wheat and soybeans, as well as raw sugar, have been stuck for several weeks outside Iranian cargo ports such as Bandar Imam Khomeini and Bandar Abbas... A spokeswoman for U.S. agribusiness company Archer Daniels Midland, which has supplied Iran, said many international banks would not participate in transactions with Iran 'for fear of being sanctioned or fined'. 'Another hindrance is Iran's foreign currency controls,' she added. 'Ships arriving in Iran with grain must frequently wait weeks for the Central Bank of Iran to approve the release of funds to pay for the cargo.' ... A banking source said: 'We should not rule out further bureaucratic delays in Iran to manage their limited availability of hard currency until sanctions are properly eased.'" http://t.uani.com/1jy2jp3

ICHRI: "A prominent member of the Iranian Parliament who sits on the Press Oversight Committee has called on the Rouhani Administration to stop what he believes is the wrongful process of newspaper closures. MP Ali Motahhari was speaking a day after the major daily Ghanoon was shut down by the Tehran Prosecutor's Office on charges of publishing a 'false' report about the release of a former Revolutionary Guards commander from detention. This is the fifth newspaper closed by the Judiciary since the election of Hassan Rouhani, a responsibility previously carried out by the Press Oversight Committee. The Judiciary's direct intervention in limiting the press is a part of a wider approach by the hardliners to bypass the Press Oversight Committee and control the press and social networking tools, and block fulfillment of pledges Rouhani made during his campaign to safeguard freedom of expression in Iran. In the case of a recent order to block the popular social networking tool, WhatsApp, however, President Rouhani pushed back against the Judiciary and took the highly unusual step of lifting the ban on the social media network. In an interview with the ISNA state news agency, MP Motahhari reminded the President and the Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance that the legal authority in charge of judging the actions of newspapers is the Press Oversight Committee." http://t.uani.com/1lnjetV

WashPost: "On the western outskirts of this city, in an industrial neighborhood of factories and dusty half-constructed lots, a metal-walled building houses women with a secret. They are female drug addicts, a growing class of people with a habit so taboo in this traditional Islamic society that some Iranians believe they deserve death. But the modest facility here, a substance-abuse rehabilitation center for women, is one sign that attitudes are slowly changing as Iran begins to confront an uncomfortable problem that long went ignored... At a conference on drugs in the city of Urmia this month, one government official blamed foreign meddling. 'The addiction of women to drugs is a trick by our enemies to attack Islamic values of Iranian families,' Razieh Khodadoust, the director general of the State Welfare Organization of Iran in the West Azerbaijan province, said at the conference. 'The enemies of the Islamic republic are planning extensively to spread drugs among Iranian women and they are investing heavily in this project.'" http://t.uani.com/RAnbAL

Foreign Affairs

AFP: "Pakistan Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif met Iran's president Sunday at the start of a visit during which talks are likely to include border security and a stalled gas pipeline deal. Sharif and President Hassan Rouhani met briefly for lunch, and will hold more in-depth talks on 'bilateral issues and the expansion of economic cooperation,' the official IRNA news agency reported. During his two-day visit Sharif, who is accompanied by senior advisers, is also expected to meet supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, Iran's ultimate authority, media reported. As he met Sharif, Rouhani said Iran was ready to develop 'road and railway networks between the two countries... as well as electric grids' in order to bolster economic ties, IRNA said." http://t.uani.com/1lbMh0m

Opinion & Analysis

UANI Advisory Board Member Irwin Cotler in JPost: "Despite Iranian President Hassan Rouhani's repeated calls for 'moderation' and 'respect for human rights in his country,' executions in Iran continue at an alarming rate. According to organizations such as the Iran Human Rights Documentation Center and Iran Human Rights, both of which track execution - and extrapolating from their data - there have been over 250 executions carried out in the first four months 2014. Indeed, there were 10 executions reported in the first five days of May alone. Ironically enough, it was Mohammad-Javad Larijani - head of the Iranian judiciary's Human Rights Council - who unwittingly highlighted these heinous crimes by declaring that the international community should be 'grateful' to Iran for the 'great service to humanity' that it provides in carrying out these executions. However, Larijani lamented that 'instead of celebrating Iran, international organizations see the increased number of executions caused by Iran's assertive confrontation with drugs as a vehicle for human rights attacks on the Islamic Republic of Iran.' But the horrific reality of executions in Iran deserves international condemnation - not celebration - while Larijani's absurd defense of his country's record is in blatant contravention of international law, and even Iranian law. First, Article 6 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political rights - to which Iran is a States Party - provides that a 'sentence of death may be imposed only for the most serious crimes.' Christof Heyns, the UN special rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions, has affirmed that executions for drug-related offenses - which Larijani seeks to justify and even celebrate - do not meet the threshold of 'most serious crimes' to which the death penalty might be lawfully applied. Moreover, a not insignificant number of the 687 people executed in 2013 - the largest number executed in a single year since the early Nineties - were convicted of other than drug-related offenses. Second, for example, the revised Islamic Penal Code of 2013 continues to impose the death penalty for a litany of other crimes that do not meet the 'most serious crimes' standard under international law, including not only drug-trafficking but also sexual relations outside marriage, 'apostasy,' and other vaguely worded political crimes such as 'enmity against God.' Finally, death sentences in Iran are frequently carried out following legal proceedings that do not meet basic fair trial standards under international law, including the use of forced confessions, the denial of a fair hearing, or the denial of any hearing at all. Accordingly, it is not surprising that the most recent US State Department Annual Human Rights Report for Iran documents some of the 'most egregious atrocities in recent memory' in 2013... Rouhani's talk of freedom and reconciliation is a welcome change from former president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's frequently incendiary rhetoric and incitement. It is the responsibility of the international community to ensure that Rouhani's actions reflect his words - a far cry from the tragic human rights reality of the Iranian people. As Mahmood Amiry-Moghaddam of IHR put it: 'It is a paradox that the relations between Iran and the international community are improving while the number of the executions in Iran increases.'" http://t.uani.com/1olNFnu

Robert Einhorn in The National Interest: "But on several other critical issues, the EU/P5+1 and Iran remain far apart. Nowhere is the gap greater than on the size and composition of the uranium enrichment program that Iran would be allowed to possess under the comprehensive agreement. To lengthen the time it would take Iran to break out of an agreement and produce enough weapons-grade uranium for a single nuclear weapon, the EU/P5+1 would like to see a major reduction in the number of Iranian centrifuges and the amount of enriched uranium stockpiled in Iran. Tehran says it wants to expand its current enrichment capacity substantially. In a recent press interview, Salehi said that, in addition to the roughly 19,000 centrifuges currently installed, Iran will need to build an additional 30,000 in order to produce fuel for the Bushehr power reactor, which Iran bought from Russia and for which the Russians are currently supplying the enriched fuel. Moreover, Salehi asserted that Iran would need to produce fuel for 'other Bushehrs in the works,' and suggested that fueling such power reactors would require the Natanz enrichment facility to operate with 50,000 centrifuges that are fifteen times more efficient than Iran's first-generation centrifuges that are now operating. An enrichment capacity that large-indeed, an enrichment capacity greater than a few thousand first-generation centrifuges-would give Iran an unacceptably rapid breakout capability. If Tehran's position at the negotiating table is a reflection of Salehi's public remarks, it is a show-stopper, and Iran must know that. Iran doesn't need a large enrichment capacity in the near or medium term to pursue a technically sound, sensibly paced, and successful civil nuclear-energy program. It can achieve its civil nuclear goals with a much more limited capability consistent with the requirements of a deal acceptable to the EU/P5+1. Under the kind of agreement that may be negotiable, Iran could have sufficient enrichment capability to fuel the few research reactors it plans to build to produce medical isotopes, test fuel assemblies, and conduct nuclear research. To meet its electricity-generation needs, it could continue to buy nuclear power reactors and enriched uranium to fuel those reactors from Russia and possibly other foreign vendors. And it could benefit from collaboration with the P5+1 and other advanced nuclear energy countries in the design, construction, and fueling of modern research and power reactors. If Iran is serious about having an advanced civil nuclear program in the long run, it makes little sense either to operate large numbers of obsolete first-generation centrifuges or to compete with much more experienced and lower-cost foreign enrichment operations in an effort to provide fuel for its power reactors (which require many times more fuel and enrichment capacity than research reactors). A wiser strategy is to use a relatively small number of its current centrifuges to meet near-term research-reactor requirements, rely on more cost-effective foreign suppliers to address the much greater enriched-uranium needs of its power reactors (as countries like Japan do), and make progress toward a more advanced civil nuclear program in the future through domestic research and development and collaboration with Russia and the West." http://t.uani.com/1g1muvK

Eye on Iran is a periodic news summary from United Against Nuclear Iran (UANI) a program of the American Coalition Against Nuclear Iran, Inc., a tax-exempt organization under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code. Eye on Iran is not intended as a comprehensive media clips summary but rather a selection of media elements with discreet analysis in a PDA friendly format. For more information please email Press@UnitedAgainstNuclearIran.com

United Against Nuclear Iran (UANI) is a non-partisan, broad-based coalition that is united in a commitment to prevent Iran from fulfilling its ambition to become a regional super-power possessing nuclear weapons.  UANI is an issue-based coalition in which each coalition member will have its own interests as well as the collective goal of advancing an Iran free of nuclear weapons.

No comments:

Post a Comment