Wednesday, December 18, 2013

Eye on Iran: U.S. Pessimism Sets in Over Iran Nuclear Talks








For continuing coverage follow us on Twitter and join our Facebook group.
  
Top Stories

LA Times:
"Three weeks after President Obama hailed a landmark deal to suspend most of Iran's nuclear program for the next six months, the mood among U.S. officials about the next round of negotiations has shifted from elated to somber, even gloomy. 'I wouldn't say [chances of success are] more than 50-50,' Obama said last week. U.S. officials are 'very skeptical' that Iran will accept Western demands, said his lead negotiator, Wendy R. Sherman. The shift, officials say, is the result of a growing recognition of the compromises each side must make to resolve the decade-old impasse over Western suspicion that Iran will someday try to build nuclear weapons and the Iranian demand that the sanctions crippling its economy be lifted. Problems already have emerged. Technical talks in Vienna aimed at implementing the initial deal stopped Thursday when Iranian negotiators unexpectedly flew back to Tehran, reportedly in response to the Obama administration's decision to expand its blacklist of foreign companies and individuals who have done business with Iran in violation of sanctions." http://t.uani.com/1bQ387d

FP: "U.S. intelligence officials believe that Iranian commandos took part in a deadly attack on a compound of dissidents inside Iraq and then spirited seven members of the group back to Iran, highlighting Tehran's increasingly free hand inside Iraq in the wake of the U.S withdrawal from the country. The Sept. 1 attack on a base called Camp Ashraf killed at least 50 members of the Mujahedeen-e Khalq, or MEK, which had disarmed at the request of the U.S. military after the American invasion of Iraq and received explicit promises of protection from senior commanders. Instead, gory videos released by the group showed that many of its members had been shot with their hands tied behind their backs or in one of the camp's makeshift hospitals. MEK leaders, backed by an array of U.S. lawmakers, said Iraqi security forces carried out the attack. Baghdad has long denied the charge, and U.S. officials have now concluded that a small number of Iranian paramilitaries from its feared Islamic Revolution Guards Corps helped plan and direct the assault on the camp. Three officials, speaking to Foreign Policy for the first time, said gunmen from two of Tehran's Iraqi-based proxies, Kitab Hezbollah and Asaib Ahl al-Haq, then carried out the actual attack. The Iranian involvement in the Ashraf massacre hasn't been reported before." http://t.uani.com/1cAhupU

Reuters: "Iran says it will resume technical talks with six world powers in Geneva on Thursday and Friday, a vital step in implementing a deal signed last month which suspends key elements of Tehran's nuclear programme in exchange for limited relief from sanctions. The talks between expert teams may continue into Saturday and Sunday if required, Fars news agency reported Iran's deputy chief negotiator, Abbas Araqchi, as saying. Last Thursday Iranian negotiators interrupted technical talks in Vienna in protest against the U.S. blacklisting of an additional 19 Iranian companies and individuals under existing sanctions, saying the move was against the spirit of the nuclear deal. U.S. officials maintain the blacklisting does not violate the November 24 agreement and say they gave Iran advance warning of the action." http://t.uani.com/1dmAgTn
 
Nuclear Negotiations

WSJ: "Talks on implementing last month's interim nuclear deal between Iran and six major powers are set to resume this week, two European diplomats said Tuesday. On Thursday, implementation talks in Vienna were put on hold after four days of negotiations when Iran reacted angrily to a U.S. decision to expand its list of Iranian sanctions targets. Over the last 48 hours, Western officials have worked to kick-start the talks. On Monday, U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry called Iranian Foreign Minister Javad Zarif to work out a way forward in the talks. On Tuesday morning, EU foreign policy chief Catherine Ashton met with Iranian Deputy Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi in Brussels to discuss the state of play. Mr. Zarif said Monday that Iran would return to the negotiations even as he hit out at what he called the U.S.'s 'improper' actions." http://t.uani.com/JB7SDO

Sanctions

Reuters: "India's oil imports from Iran fell 34.8 percent in April-November from a year ago despite a jump last month, giving New Delhi room to import more till March and still win another waiver of U.S. sanctions... India shipped in about 176,000 bpd in April-November, trade data made available to Reuters shows. The world's fourth-largest oil importer intends to buy up to an average 220,000 bpd of oil from Iran in the year ending March 31, Oil Secretary Vivek Rae said last month... India's oil shipments from Iran rose 13 percent in November from October to 219,700 bpd triggered by higher imports at Mangalore Refinery and Petrochemicals Ltd (MRPL), the data shows. MRPL began receiving fully loaded suezmax vessels at its recently commissioned single point mooring after getting full cover from a local insurer. Last month, MRPL received two suezmaxes of Iranian oil at its crude handling facility. It is not clear which company reinsured the facility... Overall oil imports from Iran in January-November fell by 38.5 percent to 196,200 bpd from 318,800 bpd in the same period last year, the data shows." http://t.uani.com/1kUQg1B

Military Matters

AP: "Iran's state TV is saying it has inaugurated a powerful new long-range radar system capable of detecting small drone aircraft. Gen. Farzad Esmaili, head of Iran's air defense headquarters, told the station that the system is named Arash, after a mythical Iranian hero. He said the radar will work on all UHF, VHF and HF frequencies and will improve Tehran's ability to engage in electronic warfare." http://t.uani.com/1fmqoKT

Human Rights

RWB: "Hassan Rouhani, a moderate conservative candidate backed by the reformists, was elected president with 51 per cent of the votes on 15 June. Despite his promises of reform and despite the release of some prisoners of conscience, including a few journalists and netizens, most of the news providers who were in prison before his election - the majority of them arrested in the wake of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's disputed reelection as president in June 2009 - are still there. At least 76 journalists have been arrested since the start of 2013, 42 of them since June. Seventeen others have been given sentences ranging from one to nine years in prison. Twelve newspapers and magazines have been suspended or forced to stop publishing under pressure from the authorities. Inhuman treatment of prisoners of opinion continues to be common. Many detainees are still denied medical care despite being very ill or in poor physical and mental health as a result of their imprisonment." http://t.uani.com/18QSrOt

AP: "Sen. Bill Nelson said Tuesday he is willing to travel to Iran if it would help find missing CIA contractor Robert Levinson who disappeared while on a secret intelligence mission to Iran. In a speech on the Senate floor, Nelson said he has spoken in recent days to Mohammad Khazaee, the Iranian ambassador to the United Nations, and pleaded on humanitarian grounds for details on Levinson, who disappeared in Iran in 2007." http://t.uani.com/18WdQZx

AFP: "The European Union must build on the momentum of the landmark nuclear deal with Iran and engage the Islamic republic on human rights, a MEP visiting Tehran said Tuesday. EU Special Representative for Human Rights Stavros Lambrinidis could 'discuss the terms of dialogue' about improving rights with the Iranian authorities, Belgian Green MEP Isabelle Durant told AFP. Durant is part of an eight-member European Parliament delegation visiting Tehran. The lawmakers had said they would meet senior Iranian officials, as well as broaching human rights issues. 'Once the process has begun, it will be difficult to interrupt it,' Durant said of the possible dialogue, stressing 'the window of opportunity will not stay open for very long.'" http://t.uani.com/1i19Wnl

Foreign Affairs

Reuters: "An Iranian businessman linked to a sprawling conglomerate controlled by Iran's supreme leader is wanted by the United States for allegedly trying to purchase hundreds of American-made assault rifles to smuggle into Iran. Behrouz Dolatzadeh was arrested in the Czech Republic last year and held in custody. He was convicted there in June of attempted arms trafficking and attempting to violate sanctions on Iran. But he was released in September after an appeals court overturned his conviction and the United States failed to request his extradition, according to interviews with Czech officials. A spokesman for the U.S. Attorney's office in Phoenix, Arizona, where Dolatzadeh was indicted, declined to comment on why no extradition request was filed. Dolatzadeh's defense lawyer in Prague, Michal Marini, says he believes Dolatzadeh is back in Iran. Iranian corporate filings show Dolatzadeh was appointed in recent years to the boards of three tech companies connected to a massive business empire controlled by Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, Iran's top cleric and most powerful man. The conglomerate's full name in Persian is Setad Ejraiye Farmane Hazrate Emam." http://t.uani.com/1khaq8r

AP: "Iran has canceled a planned $500 million loan to Pakistan to build part of a pipeline to bring natural gas from the Islamic Republic. Deputy Oil Minister Ali Majedi said Iran has no obligation to finance the Pakistani side of the project and also doesn't have the money. Iran has already invested over $2 billion to construct the Iranian side of the pipeline. But there are serious doubts about how Pakistan could finance the $2 billion needed to construct the pipeline on its territory. Iran's former president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad had pledged the loan. Pakistan has welcomed an Iranian offer to approach third parties, including European companies, to finance the project." http://t.uani.com/1kURMku

Opinion & Analysis

David Ignatius in the WashPost: "Hossein Shariatmadari's business card identifies him as the 'Supreme Leader's Representative' at Kayhan, Iran's leading conservative newspaper. Listening to his unwavering advocacy of Iran's revolutionary politics, you realize just how hard it will be to reach the nuclear agreement that many Iranians I talked with here seem to want. Shariatmadari says frankly that he doesn't believe in compromise with the West. 'The identity of both sides is involved in this conflict,' says the stern editor. 'It didn't just happen. It is structural. The problem will be solved when one side gives up its identity, only then.'  The Kayhan editor is using his powerful voice to resist the deal being negotiated by President Hassan Rouhani and Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif. He says bluntly that he doesn't think Iran should have signed the six-month freeze negotiated last month in Geneva, and he argues that Zarif misled Rouhani and Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei when he said the deal guaranteed Iran's right to enrichment of uranium. 'This gentleman [Zarif] did not tell the truth,' he asserts. Can hard-liners such as Shariatmadari and the leaders of the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps block a deal? The vanguard represented by Shariatmadari and the Revolutionary Guard may hold the commanding heights... But the radical roots of the regime are still intact. And Shariatmadari speaks for the vanguard that has internalized the message of a massive mural on Karim Khan Zand Boulevard, near his office, that shows founder Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini with the words: 'We will never put down the flag you raised.'" http://t.uani.com/1fmrEha

Amir Taheri in the NY Post: "Less than a month after it was hailed as 'a great diplomatic coup,' the so-called Geneva accord to halt Iran's nuclear ambitions seems to have come unstuck. The official narrative in Tehran is that Iran signed nothing. 'There is no treaty and no pact,' says Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Marzieh Afkham, 'only a statement of intent.' Originally, Iran's official media had presented the accord as a treaty (qarardad) but it now refers to a 'letter of agreement' (tavafoq nameh). The initial narrative claimed that the P5+1 group of nations that negotiated the deal with Iran had recognized the Islamic Republic's right to enrich uranium and agreed to start lifting sanctions over a six-month period. In exchange, Iran would slow its uranium enrichment and postpone for six months the installation of equipment for producing plutonium, an alternate route to making a bomb. A later narrative claimed that the accord wasn't automatic and that the two sides had appointed experts to decide the details ('modalities') and fix a timetable. On Sunday, an editorial in the daily Kayhan, published by the office of 'Supreme Guide' Ali Khameini, claimed that the 'six month' period of the accord was meaningless and that a final agreement might 'even take 20 years to negotiate.' It was, therefore, no surprise that Iran decided to withdraw its experts from talks in Geneva to establish exactly how to implement the accord. 'Now we have to talk about reviving the talks on modalities,' says Deputy Foreign Minister Abbas Araqchi. Translated into plain language, the new Iranian narrative is that talks about implementing an accord that is not legally binding have collapsed and that, in the words of the head of the Iranian Atomic Energy Agency, Ali-Akbar Salehi, there is no change in the rhythm and tempo of Iran's nuclear project. 'Our centrifuges are working full capacity,' Salehi said last Thursday. Having claimed that he had halted Iran's nuclear project, Secretary of State John Kerry might want to reconsider. He and his European colleagues, like many of their predecessors, may have fallen for the diplomatic version of the Three Card Monte played by the mullahs since they seized power in 1979. Khomeinist diplomacy has never aimed at reaching agreement with anyone. Instead, the regime regards negotiations as just another weapon in the jihad (holy struggle) for ensuring the triumph of 'true Islam' across the globe. The regime can't conceive of give-and-take and compromise even with Muslim nations, let alone a bunch of 'Infidel' powers. If unable to impose its will on others, the regime will try to buy time through endless negotiations. In Three Card Monte, suckers stay in the game in the hope of getting it right next time. A similar hope ensures outsiders' participation in Khomeinist diplomacy's version of the trick." http://t.uani.com/1gG2oX1

Christian Emery in the Majala: "In one important respect the interests of the two factions coincide: the Guard's economic activities have been hit hard by the effect of sanctions, and Rouhani has dedicated his foreign policy to rolling them back. Rouhani has even publicly praised the Guards' economic might and shows no inclination towards challenging their creeping wealth. Instead, what is at stake is the source of that power-political influence, access to the Supreme Leader, and ideological leadership. And on this front, Rouhani has mounted an unprecedented challenge to the IRGS. Back in September, he warned the Guards' leadership, to their face, that they should keep out of politics. When Khamenei immediately added that Iran's revolutionary vanguard had no need to involve themselves in politics, it was a clear instruction for IRGC hardliners to rein in attacks against the President. Another indication of Rouhani's determination to reduce IRGC political influence is the lack of representation it has in his cabinet. In stark contrast to the previous administration, where 60% of the cabinet were IRGC commanders, Rouhani's 18-strong cabinet contains just four. Rouhani recently backed this up by purging members of the Guards from political positions in Iran's provinces. Whether Rouhani succeeds politically will largely depend on whether he continues to enjoy the patronage of the Supreme Leader. That remains far from certain. Khamenei may well have become wary of the growing power of the IRGC, particularly during the Ahmadinejad years, but he knows their members are by and large fiercely loyal to him. Equally, Khamenei's view of the West is far closer to Jaafari's than it is to the likes of Zarif. He will want to see concrete steps from the West towards removing sanctions in response to the concessions he has authorized. Khamenei is also concerned that Rouhani might be pushing domestic reform too far, and very publicly rejected attempts to liberalize cultural policy. Even more worrying is the level of public expectation Rouhani faces to deliver significant improvements in living standards. If he fails to reverse Iran's economic woes-a daunting task-and the government is stripped of its popular appeal, Khamenei is far less likely to continue protecting his president from hard-line opponents. It's no wonder, therefore, that Rouhani and his chief lieutenants reacted so strongly to the threat of further Congressional sanctions that will inevitably undermine their ability to sell a nuclear deal at home. Iranian foreign policy has always been closely linked to the fortunes of powerful domestic factions, but failure on the nuclear issue could now frustrate Rouhani's attempt to reduce the political position of a hard-line faction accustomed to wielding considerable influence." http://t.uani.com/19SuZk0 

Eye on Iran is a periodic news summary from United Against Nuclear Iran (UANI) a program of the American Coalition Against Nuclear Iran, Inc., a tax-exempt organization under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code. Eye on Iran is not intended as a comprehensive media clips summary but rather a selection of media elements with discreet analysis in a PDA friendly format. For more information please email Press@UnitedAgainstNuclearIran.com

United Against Nuclear Iran (UANI) is a non-partisan, broad-based coalition that is united in a commitment to prevent Iran from fulfilling its ambition to become a regional super-power possessing nuclear weapons.  UANI is an issue-based coalition in which each coalition member will have its own interests as well as the collective goal of advancing an Iran free of nuclear weapons.





No comments:

Post a Comment