IPT Blogs: Rulings Crimp Odeh Defense Strategy

Steven Emerson, Executive Director	October 27, 2014
Articles by IPT |  IPT in the News |  IPT Blog |  Profiles |  Multimedia |  Donate |  Contact Us
In this mailing: Rulings Crimp Odeh Defense Strategy Egypt Cancels Hamas-Israel Talks After Sinai Attack Rulings Crimp Odeh Defense Strategy by IPT News  •  Oct 27, 2014 at 6:21 pm http://www.investigativeproject.org/4629/rulings-crimp-odeh-defense-strategy Print Send Comment RSS Share: Be the first of your friends to like this. Two orders issued Monday by a federal judge in Detroit dealt harsh blows to the defense strategy expected from attorneys for Rasmieh Odeh, the subject of a new 5-part video series by the Investigative Project on Terrorism. Odeh is scheduled to go on trial Nov. 4 on two counts of immigration fraud, stemming her conviction in an Israeli court for a 1969 terrorist bombing in Jerusalem that killed two college students. On immigration applications to come to America and later to become a citizen, Odeh failed to acknowledge her arrest, conviction and imprisonment. Odeh confessed to the bombing, but later claimed that it was the result of extended torture and mistreatment. Her allies have waged a national campaign aimed at casting her as a victim of injustice and getting the charges dropped. U.S. District Judge Gershwin A. Drain ruled that the torture claims, and a psychologist's theory that Odeh suffers from post-traumatic stress as a result, are inadmissible at trial. He reversed an original order which would have required that prosecutors prove that Odeh withheld the information about her conviction with the specific intent of illegally becoming an American citizen. The psychologist would have testified that the omission could have been a result of the PTSD. Now, "the Government need only prove [Odeh] made a false statement knowing it to be false," Drain ruled. The PTSD testimony is inadmissible. In a separate order, he rejected Odeh's motion to stop prosecutors from introducing records from the Israeli prosecution in order to prove that her conviction and 10 years in an Israeli prison really took place. That doesn't mean Drain is ruling out the possibility Odeh was mistreated and coerced into confessing. "However, the issue here is whether [Odeh] provided false answers on her Visa and Naturalization Applications," he wrote. The Israeli evidence came via a mutual treaty between the United States and Israel, he explained. The Constitution says "treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land; and the Judges in every State shall be bound thereby..." In addition, records establishing Odeh's conviction go to the heart of the case. Immigrants to the United States must show they are of good moral character before becoming citizens. By omitting that information on her application, Odeh hid information that likely would have kept her out of the country. "The probative value of this evidence is overwhelming," Drain wrote. In discussing the 1969 supermarket bombing, however, prosecutors and their witnesses are not allowed to describe it as a "terrorist" act. That, Drain ruled, would be unduly prejudicial. Odeh's attorneys also asked for another delay in the trial, saying they need more time to prepare their defense, especially in light of the late pre-trial rulings. Related Topics: Prosecutions  |  IPT News Egypt Cancels Hamas-Israel Talks After Sinai Attack by IPT News  •  Oct 27, 2014 at 12:32 pm http://www.investigativeproject.org/4628/egypt-cancels-hamas-israel-talks-after-sinai Print Send Comment RSS Share: Be the first of your friends to like this. Following a deadly terrorist attack on Friday in Sinai, Egypt prevented a senior Hamas delegation from entering the country to participate in indirect discussions between the Palestinians and Israel. Hamas official Khalil Haya confirmed to the Hamas daily Al-Resalah that the terrorist group was denied access into Egypt, the Times of Israel reports. Earlier, Egyptian President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi claimed that foreign actors were involved in a suicide car bombing that killed over 30 soldiers in el-Arish. Deputy Interior Minister Samih Bashadi went even further and blamed "Palestinian operatives" for the attack. Bashadi asserts that the Sinai can only be stabilized after the creation of a buffer zone between the Gaza Strip and Sinai Peninsula. These developments come in light of Hamas' attempts to reconcile with the Egyptian government. However, Egypt is convinced that Hamas continues to engage in the planning and execution of terrorist acts within its borders. Related Topics: IPT News
The IPT accepts no funding from outside the United States, or from any governmental agency or political or religious institutions. Your support of The Investigative Project on Terrorism is critical in winning a battle we cannot afford to lose. All donations are tax-deductible. Click here to donate online. The Investigative Project on Terrorism Foundation is a recognized 501(c)3 organization.   To subscribe: http://www.investigativeproject.org/list_subscribe.php The Investigative Project on Terrorism 202-363-8602 - main 202-966-5191 - fax