Why
Egypt Supports U.S. Withdrawal From Iran Nuclear Deal
by Hany Ghoraba
Special to IPT News
May 22, 2018
|
|
|
|
Share:  
|
  Be the
first of your friends to like this.
 President Trump's
decision to withdraw from the Iran nuclear deal focused understandable
attention on the parties which negotiated it. But the move also carries
implications for other regional states, including Egypt.
In 2015, Egypt welcomed any initiative to stop a nuclear arms race in
the region, but viewed the negotiations skeptically. "We would hope
that the agreement reached between the parties would be comprehensive and
fulfilling that would prevent an arms race in the Middle East and the
complete elimination of all weapons of mass destruction, including nuclear
weapons," said
Egyptian foreign ministry spokesman Bader Abdul Atti. Three years later,
former Egyptian Foreign Minister and incumbent Arab League Secretary
General Ahmed Aboul Gheit expressed the same skepticism, saying the agreements
focus solely on the nuclear program; it "is not the only element that
should be pursued with Iran because it implements policies in the region
that lead to instability."
While the deal limited Iran's uranium enrichment for a limited time,
Iran never stopped supporting terrorist groups targeting Egypt, including
the Muslim Brotherhood, Hamas and Hizballah. And the deal failed to address
Iran's expansionist ambitions in the region.
Egypt has been in conflict with Iran's Islamist regime since the 1979
revolution ousted Shah Mohammad Reza Pahlavi and led to Ayatollah
Khomeini's ascent to power. Egypt provided refuge to the dethroned Shah a year after
Egypt signed a peace treaty with Israel at Camp David in
1978. In response, Iran ended direct flights to Egypt in 1979, and broke
off all diplomatic relations with Egypt in 1980. Egypt remains the only
Arab country without an embassy in Tehran.
Iran provoked Egyptians years later by naming a main street in Tehran in honor of Khalid Islambouli, an Egyptian terrorist who
assassinated President Anwar Sadat during a 1981 military parade. The
street name remains,
despite an Iranian promise aimed at improving relations, and new
larger-than-life wall graffiti of the terrorist decorate buildings in Tehran.
That form of animosity from Iran was met by Egypt's full support to the
Iraqi state war against Iran (1979-1988) in which Egypt sold Iraq large
amounts of its surplus Soviet-made weapons. Despite being in a major feud
with Iraq as a result of Iraq's role in rallying the Arab states to boycott
Egypt after the Camp David treaty, Egypt still chose to support Iraq
against the Islamist regime, recognizing the greater long-term threat of
Iran on Egypt and the entire region.
Iranian espionage operations in Egypt spiked with multiple Iranian cells
uncovered trying to infiltrate Egyptian society and
institutions. In one example, Iran used a former Muslim Brotherhood member
to attempt to establish
a radical Shiite Islamist political party in Egypt under the name Shiite
Liberation Party to promote Iranian Islamic revolution policies. Hizballah,
Iran's terrorist proxy, planned terrorist attacks against Egyptian targets.
Egyptian authorities arrested 49 Hizballah members in 2009 for planning
three bombings in Taba, a city that borders Israel. The cell's members
managed to escape and flee the country after Hamas terrorists broke into the Wadi Al Natroun jail in January 2011
amid the 2011 uprising against Hosni Mubarak's government. One, Sami
Shehab, appeared later in Lebanon at a Hizballah celebration.
Iran frequently hosts and supports Muslim Brotherhood leaders including
former spokesman Kamal Al Hilbawy and Swiss-based financier Youssef
Nada. Nada claims that he is simply seeking peace initiatives between
Arabs and Iranians, but in reality he worked to bolster Iran's regional influence by routing intelligence from Muslim Brotherhood affiliates
in Arab countries to Iranian operatives.
During a 2016 meeting with Iranian Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei, Hilbawy described Ayatollah
Khomeini as being his mentor as influential to Muslim Brotherhood members
as their founder Hassan al-Banna and Brotherhood ideologue Sayyid Qutb.
"We always say that we learned from Imam Khomeini as much as we
learned from Imam Hassan al-Banna, Imam Maududi, Imam Sayyid Qutb ... and
we are still learning from our brothers who are alive here [in Iran],"
Hilbawy said.
He reaffirmed
Muslim Brotherhood and Iranian animosity towards the United States:
"We saw with our own eyes how the Soviet Union collapsed thanks to God
... and I pray to God Almighty we would witness the renaissance of Islam
and unity of the Muslim Ummah, so we can see with our own eyes the
overtaking of the remaining superpower (USA) as it falls and divides in
front us day after day."
Iran, Hilbawy said, is the only country that the West fears and he hopes
Iran becomes a model for the rest of the Arabic and Islamic world.
For nearly three decades, Iran has been a major financier for Hamas – the
Muslim Brotherhood's Palestinian terror wing, which has been an obstacle
for a sustainable peace between Palestinians and Israelis. Hamas also has
worked to destabilize Egyptian national security and the peace agreement
with Israel. It compromised Egyptian national security by digging tunnels to smuggle personnel, weapons and
commodities, which has led the Egyptian army to launch a major campaign to destroy thousands of these tunnels across the
Egyptian/Gazan border in the past years.
Critics say the nuclear deal's terms
gave Iran a clear path toward developing a bomb once the deal ends. Egypt
is well aware of this fact and the threat posed by Iran's developing
ballistic missiles capabilities. The Khorramshahr
medium-range missile tested last September can travel 2,000 kilometers with
a payload of 1,800 kilograms. Once operational, it can reach Tel-Aviv. If
it can travel 700 kilometers further, it can reach Cairo. Egypt, therefore,
is understandably concerned about sanction relief that helps Iran fund such
offensive missile technology.
Furthermore, Iran's hegemonic ambitions include financing Yemen's
Shi'ite Houthi rebels who toppled their government in 2014 and controlled
the Yemeni capital Sana'a. That move gave Iran control of the Bab-al Mandeb
strait and thus threatens Egypt's military and commercial interests in
the Red Sea.
Moreover, Iran-backed allies are gaining ground politically, with
Hizballah winning 13 parliament seats in recent Lebanese
elections. Iranian-backed Houthi fighters have held Yemen's capital Sanaa for four years.
Accordingly, Egyptian officials believe that the United States
withdrawing from the nuclear deal may be a step to slow Iran's expansion
and stop the region from falling into further chaos. While most agree on
the Iranian threat to Egyptian interests, political strategist Ahmed Sarhan said it
might have been better "re-negotiating the deal... not breaking it
while [the U.S.] kept pressuring Iran to stop their regional
hostility."
But political analyst Amr Bakly, director of Cairo Liberal Forum, praised the
move. "The last three years have proven the failure of all the Obama
administration's attempts to contain the Iranian regime. The end result was
Iran receiving funds and economic privileges that enabled the regime to
contain the rising domestic anger against it and sustain its continuous
infiltration of the region through funding of the insurgency and instability
in Yemen, Iraq, Syria and Lebanon," he said.
"I do not think that increasing pressure on Iran could negatively
affect the stability in the region, because since the signing of the deal
by Iran, its foreign policies have not changed and therefore the world has
to deal with the Iranian regime by its true nature. I believe that the
outcome of the recent Lebanese elections has accelerated Trump's decision
to withdraw from Iran's deal," Bakly said.
In 2014, Iranian MP Ali Reza Zakani bragged that Iran controls four Middle Eastern capitals
– Damascus, Beirut, Baghdad and Sana'a in Yemen – demonstrating its expansionist ambitions in the region. Egypt will not
sit idle watching a fifth capital added to that list and hence, welcomes
curbing the Iranian regime by the United States.
Hany
Ghoraba is an Egyptian writer, political and counter-terrorism
analyst at Al Ahram Weekly, author of Egypt's
Arab Spring: The Long and Winding Road to Democracy and a
regular contributor to the BBC.
Related Topics: Hany
Ghoraba, Iran
nuclear agreement, ballistic
missiles, Egypt-Iran
relations, Bader
Abdul Atti, Arab
League, Hizballah,
Hamas,
Iranian
revolution, Khalid
Islambouli, Kamal
Hilbawy, Muslim
Brotherhood, Ahmed
Sarhan, Amr
Bakly
|
Print
Send
RSS
Posts
No comments:
Post a Comment